You are viewing bsc_snark

Baby-sitters Club Snark-fest! - Babysitters' Winter Vacation, pt. 2 [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Dissecting the unintentional hilarity of The Baby-sitters Club.

[ tags | BSC-Snark Tags ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]

Babysitters' Winter Vacation, pt. 2 [Jun. 16th, 2014|01:26 am]
Previous Entry Share Next Entry

bsc_snark

[anabellabobella]
[Tags|, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ]

Shall we continue on the fail-train?

For posterity: Prologue - Chapter 4

I wrote this about ten hours ago, but wanted to run chapter 7 by a couple friends of mine who are black for their thumbs-up after first consulting them about something that happens in that chapter.  It's a sensitive topic that is dealt with in a very snark-worthy way, and so I feel what what I say needs to get approval of people who have experience dealing with real, true, major racism (one whose family even had to move out of where they were in Texas because of how bad the threats were and how little help they were getting from the police).  So that chapter snark has their approval EXACTLY as it will be posted, and future Jessi-chapters will also be given to them to read first and approve or smack me upside the head.

Head-desk, face-palm this way.


Chapter 5

After they got back to the loge, the kids were straving, and no one knew what to do since all the teachers went 30 miles away to the hospitle.

You guessed it.  This is a Claudia chapter.

Well, they get to the lodge, and these kids perk up and get excited.  Bull shit.  Ann has very obviously never seen a kid after a severe accident.  Only Pinky (this name will bother you more later) asked where the teachers were.  You know, the only adults she knows on the trip.  Naturally a crowd gathers to gawk at the kids like they're a side-show.

They decide to have dinner, and you'd think Claudia would know how diabetes works by now. [Stacey] shouldn’t skip meals. It messes up her blood sugar or something.  Or something.  Claudia gets a jab in how how Camp Mohawk has some food Stacey can't eat, but the people at the lodge are nice and don't serve meal items Stacey can't eat.  Good this this was over 20 years ago.  Try finding one meal you could serve to hundreds of people that won't be on someone's medical- or religiously-restricted list.  Don't even bother with moral preferences.  Just try the medical and religious first.  If you can find a meal or two, see if they pass the vegan test.  No white sugar.  No yeast.  Good luck.

So the teachers and the Georges have a meeting, and the BSC is invited to sit in.  Of course.  What else would we expect?  That the BSC might be put in charge of the kids?

Mrs. George says that the man-teacher who went through the storm had several broken ribs.  I can tell you, from having had a few broken ribs, that a bunch of broken ribs would kid of mean you can't trudge through the snow for two miles.  The lady-teacher had a broken arm.  The bus driver had a broken leg.  Somehow of the 16 kids, only one had an injury, and only minor.  Can't deprive the BSC of a chance to be heros, can we?  And got to get those meddling kids, I mean, meddling adults, out of the picture somehow.

Something meant to be a minor point in the book, but will be important to something I say later, is that these kids are very poor, and they won this trip.  Some of them have never been out of the Conway Cove area.  This trip is a massive, huge deal because, unlike the BSC, these kids aren't taking several vacations a year.

Here's the only funny thinks Claudia says, or thinks anyway.

“We could help,” I whispered. “We could watch the kids.”

Kristy smiled. “Exactly what I was thinking. Should I say something?”

“Nothing ever stopped you before.”

Ooh. If looks could kill . . .

Hehehe!!

Well, as you can guess, the adults are touched, Mrs. George cries, and I would throw my computer across the room, but I don't want two broken devices in one day.



I've got to go see what strings I can pull to get my three-day-old iPad (yes, it's new) replaced.  So my computer is safe.

Oh, even better, they'll gladly move out of their rooms and in with the kids.  Ashley's going to have that dorm all to herself.  She's this series' Luna Lovegood.  In other words, she kids ass.  Too bad there's no Harry, et. al. to accept her, strangeness and all.  One of the most touching moments in the entire HP series is when they go to her home looking for her in the last book, and Harry sees that she painted all of their faces on the ceiling her her bedroom, with a ribbon winding around them that said "Friends."  Tell me if that doesn't touch your heart.

Back to the shit-show.

So all 16 kids plus 7 babysitters will be in one dorm.  Well, Timberline Lodge (remember, Ann just decided that this lodge is a replica of the one used in The Shining) doesn't have a dorm that sleeps that many.

Pinky's ankle starts to hurt.  It's slightly sprained.  Either it is, or it isn't.  What it can be is mild.


Chapter 6

Mary Anne shows her distrust for Logan.  In her entry to him, she says, I should have been excited about the day that lay ahead, but I couldn’t work up any enthusiasm. All I could think about was you and Aruba and whatever you were doing down there. I guess there are a lot of beautiful girls on an island like that. I'm not bothering to comment on this.  All I can do is shake my head.  And say Natalee Holloway, just to be a killjoy.  No, wait, the killjoy is this book.

We get a run-down on bunks again, and Pinky is the one no one wants to share with.  I want to introduce her to Ashley and tell them to go give the rest of the kids and the BSC a bunch of hell.

Mrs. Halliday pops in to tell them that she and the Conway Cove teachers will be dorm supervisors for the kids.  Thank the gods, someone actually put some adults in charge, at least as puppets for the BSC.

The kids got over their trauma in record time, and all of them except the unfortunately-named-one go outside to play.  Poor kid.  Jessi's staying with her.

Mary Anne decides to start on her extra credit project as "historian," and finds an old legend of a ghost, and pisses herself.  She rushes off to interview the cook who decides to freak her out and be all cryptic.  Did he ever see a ghost? Maybe I have, and maybe I haven’t. I love him.



Hello, Mary Anne. Come and play with us. Come and play with us, Mary Anne. Forever … and ever  … and ever.

Mary Anne responds by writing a Logan a letter that starts,

My dearest Logan,

You can’t possibly know how much I miss you. My thoughts are with you and only you every second of every day. During the night, you fill my dreams. I cannot bear to be apart from you.

And goes on...for six pages.
The entire last page consisted of xxx’s and ooo’s.

Mary Anne is scarier than those twins.


Chapter 7

Before I get into this chapter, I just want to make something clear.  I don't approve of racism, and I understand some people have lived through hell and are more sensitive to comments and such.  Aside from the book Keep Out, Claudia, the only "racism" we've ever heard of Jessi experiencing is that Stoneybrook didn't roll out the welcome wagon, which they never roll out anyway.  I strongly disapprove of how these books handle issues of race.  Someone apparently decided that the appropriate way is to have Jessi project beliefs of racist intent onto people who are doing absolutely nothing to give that idea.  In fact, we see her being welcomed very quickly (Dawn moved to Stoneybrook months before her first book, and still had no friends), never being treated as an inferior person even by their enemies, and Jessi even has no trouble being cast in lead ballet rolls in a time when race, even more than today, was a big factor in deciding who to cast.  Unlike in BSC in the USA, her grandma isn't here to tell her to put a sock in it and stop accusing an innocent person of racism.  So while I'll be aiming my comments at Jessi, they're really aimed at Ann herself for thinking this is all appropriate.

Onward.  Downward.  Since shit's about to go down.

Kristy asks whose going skiing, and Jessi almost said yes.  Thanks to several paragraphs of her playing the worst-case-scenarios on her head of every winter activity, including amputations, she says no because someone needs to watch Pinky Winkler.  That kid can't get a break.  Mary Anne offered, since she genuinely wanted to stay inside, but no no no, Jessi really wants to.  Well, not really.  Pinky's just a cop-out for not doing what she wants to do because she's a ballerina, and ballerinas who are 11 must deprive themselves of fun.

Let's just start off with me showing you what to expect.

Jessi says they'll have lots of fun.

“It’ll be swell,” said Pinky dispiritedly.

I cringed slightly, remembering that none of the little kids had wanted Pinky for their bunkie. What was wrong with her? I wondered. Oh, well. I couldn’t worry about that. I need an excuse, and Pinky was a good one.

First off, no kid says "swell" without being sarcastic.  Second, can you think of any reasons Pinky might not be happy?

1) She's a poor kid who has never been on a trip, and now she's stuck inside watching the other kids.
2) She's injured.
3) She probably wants her parents.
4) She's the bully-target for her entire class, and no one is enthused about being with her, even the BSC.
5) She's once again not getting to be one of the group.
6) She can't go ice skating, skiing, or anything else.
7) She has no TV, none of her books, nothing to pass hours upon hours of time.

I could say she is staying with someone who only sees her an an excuse, but she doesn't know that.

Also fuck you, Jessi, for thinking there must be something wrong with Pinky instead of the kids who bully her.

Jessi and Pinky are finally alone, and Jessi, who has made it clear she's dismayed at being with this kid, starts an inquisition into Pinky's name.  Is it her real name?  Nope.

Sheesh. I was just trying to make conversation. “What’s your real name, then?” I asked.

“Priscilla.”

“I like Pinky better,” I told her.

“I don’t.”

Priscilla. Can't go off calling her Prissy now.



So she gets a nickname that's a slang for a white person.  Ann really failed hard on naming this kid.  Lose-lose.  Poor girl is stuck with a nickname she doesn't like, is injured, can't play, and is with someone who doesn't want to be around her.  $10 if you can guess what Jessi says next.

Whoa. This was one bratty little kid. No wonder none of the other children had wanted her for a bunkie.

Jessi, SHUT THE FUCK UP.  My god, you're supposed to be a genius with kids, and you can't get your head out of your ass long enough to realize there are many really good reasons this kid isn't happy right now!  Why don't you try talking about how she feels instead of thinking she's a brat?  Next thing we know, you'll be thinking she's a racist or something.

Priscilla (if this kid's going to get one break, it'll be me, and all of you, calling her by the name she prefers) does tell Jessi she doesn't like being asked a bunch of personal question and to stop talking to her.  Anyone who knows kids can easily envision one in a bad mood saying, "Stop talking to me," and pouting, and none of us would think anymore more than the kid's in a bad mood.

Ah, what do you know.  We hear about a throw-away neighbor who we have never heard of, and won't hear about again, ever.  Not once.  She's apparently got a neighbor across the street who is a rampant racist who talks about home values being dragged down by non-white people, and is basically loud enough about it to make Westboro Baptist leaders sound like peaceful neighbors to have around.  Since we are only told this and are never shown, and there is plenty of opportunity to work this mystery neighbor into the story (nope, not the one in Keep Out, Claudia, since this one has only one child), I'm going to have to question how reliable of a narrator Jessi is, and whether or not there's another reason the child of that house isn't allowed to play with Becca and Jessi's just reading racism into it.  I'm pretty sure someone who is that much of a supremacist would have factors into another book somehow.  Claudia didn't even know people really were racist until that one After-school Special of a book, and I just don't see how that could happen with a close neighbor who hates non-whites so much.  The Ramseys are NOT the only black people in town, and the Kishis aren't the only Asians.

Also it should come as no surprise that Jessi has come to the conclusion that Priscilla isn't happy because she's a racist in the company of a black person.  Today I ran this by a couple friends of mine who are black and who I know read the series, one whose family actually had to move because of threats against them for being black.  I send them this chapter via e-mail, and asked them both, "Is there anything in Pinky's behavior that should make Jessi think she's racist?"  Both of them said no, and the one whose family had to move said even if Jessi had experienced any major racism, there's still nothing racist in any of Pinky's behavior.  I wanted to cover my bases here and make sure I'm not overlooking anything due to racial privilege, and since they both said there's nothing even hinting at Pinky being racist and tons of reasons she isn't smiling, I don't feel bad ripping into how this is all going to go down.

Jessi decides she's going to talk to Priscilla anyway and make her play a game.  What a way to ensure the kid doesn't like you. She spends a good deal of time looking for a game, and then returns.

“Took you long enough,” Pinky greeted me.

I almost said something really nasty to her, but I held my tongue. Insulting a person never helps a bad situation. Besides, Pinky’s foot hurt her, and she’d had a bad scare the day before. I needed to keep things in perspective.

Jessi, again, shut up.  You're forcing a game on a kid who wants to be left alone, and then think you have the right to act hurt when she's not bothering to be nice to you.  You're not being nice to her, or respecting her.  Also, that perspective?  You don't have it now, and won't have it at all in this book.  So go take a flying leap and land on an oil slick.

Priscilla wants a soda.  Jessi bitches about being the kid's maid.  See, she forgot she volunteered to stay with a kid who can't walk.  So Jessi decides to pummel the kid in every game until the injured, scared kid she already knew was in a bad mood behaved in a way you'd expect a small child to react, and called her a cheater.  Jessi, the oh-so-mature one, storms off, grabs a book, thrust the book into Pinky’s hands, bitches at her, and went to sit in another room, and isn't going to speak to Priscilla again until lunchtime.

Ladies and gentlemen, this is the girl who we're supposed to think is mature enough to babysit for a whole weekend, who we're supposed to believe is better with kids than her aunt, who is supposed to be an expert in children, yet the first thing she does is mentally accuse an injured kid who wants to be left alone of racism.  This is like when you're on a psyche hold and you're accused of being anti-social for not wanting to sing karaoke (this really happens).  It doesn't mean you hate anyone.  Sometimes people just want to be left along instead of being forced to socialize with strangers when there's something else you really want to do instead.

Since Jessi is so infuriating, and will get worse, I'm doing another chapter.


Chapter 8

Stacey's going to meet
the world’s cutest guy today. His name is Pierre. His family is French, but Pierre was born in the U.S. and has lived here all his life. He doesn’t speak with an accent. In fact, he admitted that he doesn’t even speak much French. Pierre has these deep brown eyes that twinkle. I mean, they’re really sparkly. And his voice is starting to change, which is so cool . . .

Because a boy's voice cracking is sexy, right?  Read between the lines.  The boy's reached puberty.  He's probably got a chest hair or two, maybe a pube sprouting it he looks really hard (and teen boys apparently do).  His hormones are going to be going wild.  If you had or have a teen brother, you know they really start to reek too.  I'm so glad I don't have a son when I remember my brother's nasty smelliness during those years.

All of this is giving Stacey tinglies in places some people think girls shouldn't know about yet.  She tells us she could have written for several pages in that book for Mary Anne, but she didn’t think Mary Anne need quite such detailed information. Besides, some of my thoughts about Pierre were personal.

Put two and two together and you know EXACTLY what she's thinking.

Boy-crazy Stacey is having sex thoughts, and this is refreshing because it's actually realistic.  Which makes the lack of supervision on this whole trip really dangerous.

In her hormone-haze, she starts lamenting about how there's no chance of New York City ever getting a blizzard.  The one that happened 11 years before this book was published is just a figment of our imaginations.  Since she was born in 1973 (1985 is when the club started, and she was 12, so 1973), she should remember that story.  I'm ignoring the time warp for a moment.

No, that's a lie.



It's just a jump to the left.
And then a step to the right.
With your hand on your hips.
You bring your knees in tight.
But it's the pelvic thrust.
They really drive you insane.
I love Rocky Horror.  And I'm mentally adding the 4 years between the start of the club and this book's publication onto Stacey's age.  Just so I don't feel so skeevy not giving a rat's ass about how she's probably going to give away her v-card in this book.  There are some heavy hints to come.

Blah blah, a couple pages of filler on getting the kids dressed again, then Stacey's on the slopes, a gorgeous guy lands right on top of her.  You know what really drives you insane.

They try to get up, fall again, be cites how it's like a Laurel and Hardy sketch, and she cites Three Stooges.  What kind of teenagers know enough about Laurel and Hardy to know what their schticks were?

We do get a cute piece where they introduce themselves, find out where the other is from, and we get a believable lead-in to her knowing about him being French aside from just the name.  He's from a school close to the border, and she asks if he's French-Canadian.  This is geographically reasonable.  No, he's not French-Canadian, but his parents are from France and moved to the US after they got married.  He speaks no French, only some Italian.  Stacey asks if he speaks any French at all, and he replies, “Chevrolet coupé.”  So I like the kid.

She makes a few more slope runs, then checks on the kids who are with Mrs. Halliday, and bails to go back to Pierre.  She thought of his voice as they skied.
It was changing, acquiring that deepness.  Read into that what you will.  We're all thinking it.  I swear the way Stacey's written in this book reminds me so much of when I was her age having those thoughts for the first time.  Ah, his name was Jason Odegaard, and he was the principal's son.  I thought his glasses were so cute.  I was such a nerd.

Stacey's really crushing on the guy, and I'm on Team Stacey in this book.  She's pretty much going to disappear from this book until chapter 22. Bow chicka bow wow....





Wait until we get to the WTFery with Claudia.  Mallory will be pretty much age-appropriate.  Dawn will manage to be sympathetic.  Mary Anne will continue needing therapy.  Kristy will continue being Kristy.  Jessi will make you want to scream and ban her from being around kids.  Stacey's off experiencing "the world."

We will also have a return of bunkie-politics.

And I?  I'm going to enjoy some Earl Grey tea, see if I can find any of my old crushes on Facebook, and watch some My Little Pony since season 4 is now on Netflix and I'm kind of a die-hard.  For those of you too young to remember the original series, there were people in it.  Try to imagine people in Ponyville.
LinkReply

Comments:
[User Picture]From: bellapalmera
2014-06-16 12:07 pm (UTC)

(Link)

"...Pinky Winkler. That kid can't get a break."

I know, right? Even her ankle's only sprained.

Thank you, I'll be here all week. =P

ETA: I enjoy how the quote "'It’ll be swell,' said Pinky dispiritedly." happened right after I posted the above. I should(n't) read these at 8am when I've just woken up.

Edited at 2014-06-16 12:09 pm (UTC)
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-16 05:17 pm (UTC)

(Link)

*throws rotting tomatoes and heckles* :D
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-16 04:55 pm (UTC)

(Link)

There's a reason I don't like Jessi in most books and it has nothing to do with race and EVERYTHING to do with her attitude. As someone who was bullied a lot in school, it pisses me off so damn much that her first thought is 'child is bullied therefore something is wrong with child' because, you know, children are sweetness and light and unicorn farts and can't be downright fucking CRUEL just for the hell of it or anything.

*deep breath*

As much as I hate to say it, though, I had the same thoughts about skiing at 11 that Jessi did, because I was training my ass off to start showing horses the next year. BUT I didn't have the oppritunity to ski. Once I was in the presense of activities that might mean months out of the saddle, I did them anyway because I was a KID and kids have notoriously bad impulse control. Also, ADD.

You know it's a horrible book when Stacey being in "luv" is the least annoying plot. *headdesk* Can't wait for more! :D
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-16 05:21 pm (UTC)

(Link)

For someone who claims to dislike people making presumptions about her, she does that all the time. She looks down on people left and right.

I'd have been worried about a sprained ankle too, but ballet's going to figure later into this book because of course it is.

Stacey's "luv" plot is the most believable plot. This time she actually calls it a crush. :)

Something's wrong when DAWN ends up being a sympathetic character. And that'll happen. Because this is the BSC-light Zone.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-17 11:41 pm (UTC)

(Link)

Personal growth! She knows what a crush is! Too bad she'll forget by the time Wes "Hot For Teacher" comes to town. I had to shower several times during the course of reading that one!!!

Ballet comes into it later because Ann somehow believes that a person is only allowed one interest in life. I have two passions and many other interests that are important to me. Suck that, Ann. :P

BSC-light Zone? I love it! XD Invasion of the BSC-Snatchers!
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 12:11 am (UTC)

(Link)

Her crush on Wes is going to be very small beans compared to Claudia's crush in this book. I am seriously uncomfortable picturing some of her daydreams. Realistically Wes would have been in the age range of 20-22. Claudia's crush is old enough to have changed her diapers. And it gets worse than that.

We will "see" ballet in this book. Just...just wait.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-18 12:17 am (UTC)

(Link)

I am looking forward to it! XD
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-18 02:58 am (UTC)

(Link)

Are Stacey and Claudia the 'most sophisticated' or the 'most likely to end up at the center of a statuory rape case?'

I don't remember the ballet part...can't wait to see it! XD
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 05:31 am (UTC)

(Link)

At least Stacey's crush didn't involve explicit daydreams about... Well, you'll see.

The ballet part in this book will show how delusional Jessi is about her greatness.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-19 03:18 am (UTC)

(Link)

No, thankfully we were spared that, lol.

Oh man, Jessi is so far up her own ass she needs a glass naval to see. I don't really think it's healthy for an eleven year old to think she's the God's biggest gift to ballet since Barishnacoff.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-19 06:06 am (UTC)

(Link)

"so far up her own ass she needs a glass naval to see"

I LOVE THAT!

And Baryshnikov. :D

Jessi is 11. She is barely old enough to be on pointe for half an hour a week, and to be on point, you have to be in classes at least 4x a week. She's not. She's taking as few classes as a level 1. (I'm a ballet-mom, and an ex-dancer.)
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-20 02:58 am (UTC)

(Link)

I am so glad to read your take on it, since you actually know something about ballet. Unlike Ann, who probably saw it on TV once and went 'hey, one of my characters should be a prima ballerina. Research? What's research?' And I thought 11 was insanely young to be so amazing at it.

And yeah, I can't spell worth a shit. I try. And when I'm in doubt and spell check fails me, so I go for the good ol' phonics. They actually taught it at the Catholic school I went to K to 3. So blame Sister Mary I'll-Kick-Your-Ass for part of my spelling issues, lol.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-21 07:14 am (UTC)

(Link)

For an 11-year-old to be anywhere near as good as Jessi claims she is, she'd have to be in classes daily, with private lessons on top of that. Any kid on POINTE would be in at least four classes a week. My daughter goes to one of the top ballet schools in the entire country (this isn't just my opinion--her school ranks up with ABT and NYB), and pointe isn't even allowed before 11, and even only about half an hour a week or so at the barre.

Ann is so full of BS on ballet, and pretty much everything. If she had just read books for kids about ballet, she'd have found out that 12 or 13 is typical to start, but instead Jessi gets to class and is in pointe right from the start, which doesn't even happen for pros. If Ann has even asked to observe a single advanced class for research, she would know she's got some things wrong from just that class.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-23 02:59 am (UTC)

(Link)

What I don't understand....is research THAT damn hard?
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-23 07:17 am (UTC)

(Link)

I guess so. How often does Ann get anything right? Even the way schools are run?
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-24 03:01 am (UTC)

(Link)

It's a good thing she didn't have widespread internet access back then or we could REALLY be disgusted by her lack of knowledge.
[User Picture]From: lisaerin
2014-06-18 03:13 am (UTC)

(Link)

I just told my brother about Stacey's crush on Scott and he was like, "She does know that's statutory rape, right?" Then I told him about Wes and he was just like, "I'm done," and went to walk away.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 05:12 am (UTC)

(Link)

I'm going to try getting the next five chapters up tonight, if I can. I'm not feeling very well. You've got to see what going on in Claudia's next chapter.
[User Picture]From: lisaerin
2014-06-18 05:13 am (UTC)

(Link)

Feel better. It's no trouble if you can't.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-19 03:23 am (UTC)

(Link)

LOL!!!! I'm surprised Stacey who is oh so sophistacted because she's from New York, never heard of a guy getting pbusted for being with an underage girl by thirteen. I was a dork who hadn't been on a date yet at thirteen, from a small midwest town and I even knew about that!
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-19 06:11 am (UTC)

(Link)

I think most kids that age did. I don't know how Miss Sophisticate wouldn't have heard a scandal or two.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-20 02:24 am (UTC)

(Link)

Me either. If we had that stuff going down here in the Zoo...they definitely had it going down in New York, New York, Fuck Yeah.
[User Picture]From: shatisarockgod
2014-06-16 11:49 pm (UTC)

(Link)

This is the same as the others. The BSC can't handle kids that happily want to do their own thing because they know their own mind or the ones that aren't happy for whatever reason and just want to be left alone. They can only handle little puppets that are willing to do anything the BSC comes up with. And I'm with Priscilla for not liking a bunch of personal questions. Some people really love to talk about themselves, will answer any and all questions and some aren't that way. I'm not that way.

"Jessi decides she's going to talk to Priscilla anyway and make her play a game"--Exactly.

Damn, it's hard to believe the the older girls would be in their 40s if they were allowed to age naturally.
[User Picture]From: maryannespen
2014-06-17 11:49 pm (UTC)

(Link)

The BSC would've hated me. I was just as likely to play indoors as outdoors and could happily entertain myself for hours. My real life baby sitters loved it, though. Just give me a book and make sure I put it down long enough to eat dinner. XD
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 12:06 am (UTC)

(Link)

Yes Priscilla's the brat....

Jessi only needed to say, "It sucks that you're stuck in here, and it's not fair that this happened. If there's anything I can do for you or get you, just let me know, okay?" That's it. But no, she pries, then snarks the kid for wanting solitude.
[User Picture]From: road_baby
2014-06-16 11:59 pm (UTC)

(Link)

The entire last page consisted of xxx’s and ooo’s

You're not Lemony Snicket, Mary Anne. Leave the page filled with one thing to him.

Ugh. Jessi's stupid 'Pinky must be racist' thing. I mean, they just said these kids are poor and have little chance of getting a trip like this. So you don't think that her missing her once in a lifetime vacation might get her down?

We hear about a throw-away neighbor who we have never heard of, and won't hear about again

Actually she did have one scene where her daughter wanted to play with Becca and she yelled at her daughter to get the fuck away from her. But that's all. It's not an ongoing thing or anything. Also I'm very embarrassed that I remember that because BSC trivia doesn't pay anything.

I needed to keep things in perspective

Oooh! I hate this! You are not keeping things in perspective! If you were you would leave the poor girl alone rather than try to force her into being friendly!

Edited at 2014-06-17 12:45 am (UTC)
[User Picture]From: joykilldrama
2014-06-17 07:39 am (UTC)

(Link)

Oh but if BSC trivia did pay, everyone in this comm would be richer than Watson Brewer and Ed McGill combined. (And I'm sorry but Ed McGill HAS to be loaded as has been pointed out a million times in this comm.)
[User Picture]From: road_baby
2014-06-17 07:53 am (UTC)

(Link)

Yeah, I wish I had a dollar for every dumb thing I know about the BSC. I'd be able to get me a PS4 and a fancy wardrobe and every item off my Amazon wishlist! Even those $500 Jem dolls!
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-17 10:36 pm (UTC)

(Link)

Ed owns a huge Manhattan condo (you know he's not renting since no one in this world rents, which means his apartment is a condo), and Maureen works for something to do to pass the time. When she went back to Stoneybrook, she bought a house as easily as the rest of us buy shoes, meaning she bought in cash instead of financing.

Yes. The McGills are loaded. Ed is making serious bank.
From: (Anonymous)
2014-06-19 01:49 am (UTC)

(Link)

YES to the McGills being loaded. I wonder why the books focus on Watson being the rich one, when I think Ed likely made as much, if not more, than him.

It also seems odd that Stacey just accepts Kristy as being the rich one, as though Stacey can't comprehend her parents are likely just as well off even though they aren't living in a mansion.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-19 05:45 am (UTC)

(Link)

Watson's a lot more conspicuous about it. Stacey's parents live in a house or a condo, which is where most of the rest of her friends live. So it's just a normal thing, and she may not realize how unusual it is for parents to have both. Watson's the only regular-cast parent who has a mansion, which means he's more into showing it off.

Stacey's like an old roommate of mine. She grew up in a good part of town with a fairly large house. They weren't in a mansion, but in a neighborhood that was still upperclass, and it was normal to her. Everyone knows mansions are rich, but not every kid knows a nice house in a subdivision can mean rich when most of the rest of her friends lived there too, and she was rarely exposed to poor people. It wasn't until shortly before she was my roommate (we already knew each other) that she realized that her dad's job at Google was as the VP of a major department, and that he's actually rich enough to buy almost any mansion in SoCal in cash. If he had a mansion, she'd have known he was rich. But living in a normal-to-her house shielded her to a degree from how wealthy her family really is.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-17 10:48 pm (UTC)

(Link)

A scene so brief and obscure that one person in this entire comm remembers it exists. Do you remember which book? I want to read that.

I don't think Jessi comprehends what it means to be poor. Some of those kids had never been out of their immediate area at all, so a trip like this may literally be once-in-a-lifetime. Jessi's young enough to not have an idea of what institutionalized racism is in the workplace (though affirmative action basically neutralized that), so she definitely won't understand what it means that those kids are going to have a harder time because children who are that poor generally don't get to finish high school, and rarely go on to college. Children like Pinky have fewer chances than someone like Jessi whose parents fund elaborate trips for her several times a year. I think all of the BSC are so far removed from the typical American lifestyle that none of them can begin to understand what it's like, and so none of them can comprehend how big of a deal this trip is. None of those girls can see their own hypocrisy. They all, Jessi and Dawn especially, prejudge others, especially kids, and shame them mercilessly, then go off and imagine slights against themselves.

What's going on with Jessi here really helps to highlight just how much of a disconnect there is between these girls and reality.
[User Picture]From: lisaerin
2014-06-18 12:24 am (UTC)

(Link)

The book is Hello Mallory. Jessi and Mallory are outside and a girl tries to come over to play with Becca, but her mom angrily calls her inside. It doesn't mention anything about race, so it is possible that she didn't want her kid playing with strangers. Jessi also mentions that most of the kids in her ballet class have been really nice to her, but the kids of SMS haven't been. I think it would have been better if we saw it from Jessi's point of view, instead of her telling Mallory.
And Stacey said that Stoneybrook rolled out the Welcome Wagon for her and gave her family treats and coupons and directions to places. I don't know if this was directly shown in a book, though.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 12:43 am (UTC)

(Link)

Ah, so it wasn't a blatant race scene. You're right, there are many other reasons that could be. Strangers, crossing a road without a parent, she had already been called in and was ignoring her mom, etc.

We have never seen any of the kids at SMS treat Jessi poorly for her race, even in books from her POV. Cokie's supposed to be nasty, yet even she's never mentioned race. Also the BSC is pretty snotty to everyone outside the club at SMS, so it makes perfect sense that a lot of people wouldn't exactly be nice to the BSC, including Jessi. Jessi complaining about how her classmates weren't nice, when you look at her future ideas of "not nice," makes me wonder if it was nothing more than people not swooping her in fighting over which group she was going to be a part of, instead of anyone actually making racist remarks.

No, that supposed welcome wagon wasn't shown in the books, and I think it would be an exaggeration anyway. SMS alone has at least 383 students--382 on the trip, plus at least Logan who isn't there. This isn't the only middle school in town. There are thousands of students in that town, and thousands of families. Even in the "ideal" decades, you didn't have a whole town descending on you with gifts. You might get a neighbor or two stopping by to say hi, but since there wasn't any formal arrangement, it could easily happen that everyone thought other people were going to see the new people. In all my life, in all my family's moves, never once did anyone roll up to the door with casseroles and cookies, much less the whole town. Maybe in a town of 200, but note in a town with a population reasonably numbering in the area of 25,000.
[User Picture]From: road_baby
2014-06-18 01:37 am (UTC)

(Link)

The only scene I remember where someone was not being 'nice' to Jessi was that some boy was throwing spitballs at her and that another kid gave her a dirty looks. But either of those could be chalked up to her being a new girl. The only outright racism was when Mal's sorta friends were saying she was probably from Africa and stuff. But Jessi didn't face that. Only Mal heard. Maybe Mal told her about it but who knows?
[User Picture]From: kakeochi_umai
2014-06-17 11:48 am (UTC)

(Link)

Jessi, SHUT THE FUCK UP. My god, you're supposed to be a genius with kids, and you can't get your head out of your ass long enough to realize there are many really good reasons this kid isn't happy right now!
This. I love that these girls claim to be ~super sitters~ who know ~everything there is to know~ about kids, yet they are utterly clueless about how to handle kids who have anything less than a mile-wide smile on their face. If only the only sentence Pierre knew in French were the same one that I know: Putain de livre de merde (fuck this book).
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 12:04 am (UTC)

(Link)

I think the only one who might remotely understand is Mal, and that's because of how much her parents put on her.
[User Picture]From: gimere
2014-06-17 04:56 pm (UTC)

(Link)

I strongly disapprove of how these books handle issues of race.

I do, too, and I'm gonna leave it at that lest I go into a full-on rant.

Also fuck you, Jessi, for thinking there must be something wrong with Pinky instead of the kids who bully her.

THIS, oh, so much.

Sometimes people just want to be left alone instead of being forced to socialize with strangers

Exactly.

I should totally read this book, if only to see how awful it really is.

Edited at 2014-06-17 04:58 pm (UTC)
[User Picture]From: Jenny Mingus
2014-06-18 02:02 am (UTC)

(Link)

Re: Black Kids in Stoneybrook:

Jessi's "Oh woe is me being in a mostly all-white town" shtick is even more infuriating when in the Kwanzaa book, turns out there are tons of black kids coming out of the woodwork. Continuity? What's that?
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-18 05:18 am (UTC)

(Link)

Agreed. When Jessi started at SMS, there were six other black kids at that school. There were two black kids TOTAL in the town I lived when I was in jr. high and high school. They were adopted by a white couple, so were literally the only black people in town. There was no big deal about their races. Jessi wasn't the only black kid, and no one had any problem with Claudia. Claudia didn't even know racism existed until she was 13, so SB is a very tolerant place to be.

And yes! How many black kids came out? So many that I envisioned a town that's probably got far more black kids than Asian. It sounds like a pretty integrated town. Since it's all the same year, it's not like dozens of families moved in between this book and that one, which, not including time warp, happened a month or two BEFORE this (Kwanzaa is in December, and ski-time is in January and February). I don't know how she can be the only black kid (as she has claimed) when there was no shortage!
[User Picture]From: fairest1
2014-06-19 02:36 pm (UTC)

(Link)

There's probably a good chance that a few parents in the 'Brook wouldn't let their kids play with Jessi and Becca due to the fact that their parents are so irresponsible as to leave an 11-year-old in charge of two kids for a weekend. That sort of thing seems like it'd get around, even if it didn't result in an arrest. But those types are the ones who never contact the BSC because they'd rather contact someone older and more qualified.

Poor Priscilla. If I were there, I'd be scouting the lodge for books the kid would like -- potentially there's a library, and there's gotta be more than one kid who brought a few with them. Then settle the kid in a comfy chair with a footrest and read quietly with her. Restful while keeping her company and not forcing anything on her.
[User Picture]From: anabellabobella
2014-06-19 08:32 pm (UTC)

(Link)

I definitely wouldn't let my daughter out of my sight with the Ramsey girls with how utterly irresponsible the parents are. I'd be worried about what they could get into, or what those girls are allowed to do and might try convincing my daughter to do.

You think Jessi knows how to show compassion to a kid who just wants to be left to her thoughts? Nope.
[User Picture]From: fairest1
2014-06-19 09:48 pm (UTC)

(Link)

Now I want Priscilla to team up with Lou; they can escape the BSCult and hang out at the library together.